Midnight Stories

The Boy Behind the Silence · Chapter 4 of 6

Chapter 4

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

The evidence did not prove Peter Costa had caused Luca’s death.

Antonio desperately wanted it to.

He also desperately wanted it not to.

Both possibilities tortured him.

If Costa had done something, Antonio had failed to protect his son.

If Costa had done nothing, Antonio had spent five years searching for meaning in a tragedy that had none.

Dr. Nathan Ellis, the infectious-disease specialist who had treated Luca, arrived at the estate the following afternoon.

He had aged.

Antonio noticed immediately.

Gray hair now framed his temples.

His shoulders had stooped.

When he entered Antonio’s study, he looked toward the fourth floor before saying hello.

“You opened the room.”

Antonio’s eyes narrowed.

“How do you know?”

“Because five years ago you told me nobody ever would.”

Dr. Ellis sat.

Antonio placed Daniel’s documents before him.

The doctor read slowly.

His face changed when he saw the hospital payments.

“Do you recognize the employee?”

“Sean Brenner. Orderly.”

“What did he have access to?”

“Patient locations. Visitor information. Some basic charts.”

“Medication?”

“Not legally.”

“That wasn’t my question.”

Ellis looked at Antonio.

“Possibly.”

Damen leaned against the desk.

“Could someone have caused Luca’s infection?”

Dr. Ellis removed his glasses.

“No.”

Antonio’s jaw tightened.

“Certain?”

“The infection began before he was admitted. The strain was identified. Nothing here changes that.”

Antonio looked away.

A strange combination of relief and disappointment flooded him.

Then Ellis continued.

“But.”

Antonio turned.

“What?”

“Luca’s deterioration was unusually fast. We transferred him to intensive care later than I wanted.”

Antonio’s eyes sharpened.

“Why?”

“There was confusion regarding authorization and room availability.”

“What confusion?”

Ellis looked uncomfortable.

“At the time, I believed it was bureaucratic incompetence.”

“And now?”

“If someone was interfering with communications…”

Antonio’s face became cold.

“How much time did we lose?”

“I can’t tell you.”

“An hour?”

“Possibly.”

“Two?”

“Antonio.”

“How much?”

Dr. Ellis’s voice softened.

“Even if Luca had reached intensive care earlier, I cannot tell you he would have survived.”

Antonio stood and walked toward the window.

Not murdered.

Not exactly.

But possibly delayed.

Possibly manipulated.

Possibly used.

Costa had not created Luca’s illness.

But if he deliberately interfered with a dying child’s care merely to distract Antonio from a business conflict—

Antonio closed his eyes.

Damen knew what he was thinking.

“Don’t.”

Antonio turned.

“Don’t what?”

“Become the man Costa expects you to become.”

Antonio’s expression darkened.

“What man is that?”

“The one who burns down half the city before learning what’s true.”

Silence stretched between them.

Dr. Ellis left soon afterward.

Antonio remained.

Eventually Elena appeared at the door.

“You haven’t eaten.”

Antonio glanced toward her.

“You’re my housekeeper.”

“I thought I’d been promoted to endangered witness.”

Despite himself, his mouth almost moved.

Almost.

She placed a plate on the desk.

“Mia says you need soup.”

“I’m not hungry.”

“She says doctors know things.”

Antonio looked at the soup.

Then at Elena.

“How is she?”

“Thrilled to be living in a mansion.”

“That makes one of us.”

Elena walked toward the window.

For several seconds they stood quietly.

Then she said, “Daniel would have liked you.”

Antonio actually looked surprised.

“No, he wouldn’t.”

“You don’t know that.”

“I know me.”

Elena smiled faintly.

“He hated arrogant people.”

“Exactly.”

“But he respected people who kept their word.”

Antonio looked down.

“Your husband died trying to warn me.”

“Yes.”

“I didn’t protect him.”

“You didn’t know.”

“That excuse didn’t satisfy you yesterday.”

“It still doesn’t.”

Antonio looked at her.

“But,” Elena continued, “there’s a difference between responsibility and omnipotence.”

He said nothing.

“You seem to think if something bad happened anywhere near your world, you should have prevented it.”

“I had resources.”

“You’re not God, Antonio.”

His name sounded strange in her voice.

Nobody outside his family used it casually.

She noticed.

“Sorry.”

“No.”

He looked back toward Central Park.

“It’s fine.”

Elena hesitated.

“Mia likes you.”

“That concerns me.”

“She likes everyone.”

“More concerning.”

“She thinks you need fixing.”

“Impossible.”

“She’s persistent.”

“So was Luca.”

The name escaped before Antonio realized he had said it.

Everything stopped.

Elena did not react dramatically.

That helped.

She simply asked, “Was he?”

Antonio looked toward the fourth floor.

“Yes.”

His voice changed.

“He believed every problem could be solved with tape, cookies, or his doctor kit.”

Elena smiled.

“Mia’s current medical philosophy is Band-Aids cure everything.”

“Luca once put six on my forehead because I had a headache.”

Elena laughed softly.

Antonio heard it.

For five years laughter inside the estate had irritated him.

This time it did not.

He told her another story.

Then another.

By the time he realized what was happening, he had said Luca’s name seven times.

That evening, Mia found him sitting on the stairs outside the fourth floor.

She climbed up one step at a time.

“Can I see boy room?”

Antonio immediately said, “No.”

Mia sat beside him.

“Okay.”

He looked at her.

No argument.

No tantrum.

She simply waited.

Finally he asked, “Why do you want to?”

“The boy looked nice.”

“You saw his photograph.”

“Uh-huh.”

“That man speaking through the wall wasn’t a boy.”

“I know.”

Antonio frowned.

“You know?”

“He sounded old pretending little.”

Antonio stared.

“Why didn’t you tell us?”

“Nobody asked.”

Antonio closed his eyes briefly.

Children.

He would never understand them.

Mia leaned against his arm.

“Can Luca have flowers?”

Antonio’s breath caught.

“What?”

“Boy room needs flowers.”

There had been no fresh flowers in the estate for five years.

“I don’t like flowers.”

“Why?”

“Because…”

He stopped.

Because they reminded him of the hospital.

Because grief had turned an entire category of living things into enemies.

Mia waited.

Antonio looked at the locked door.

Then at her.

“What kind?”

“Yellow.”

The next morning, Rosa nearly dropped a tray.

A vase of yellow daisies sat outside Luca’s room.

Nobody mentioned who had placed them there.

Later that day, Damen brought the breakthrough.

Malcolm Price had been found.

Not by force.

By fear.

He contacted them himself.

Costa was trying to kill him.

Antonio agreed to meet.

The location was an abandoned church property in Brooklyn.

Damen objected.

Antonio went anyway.

Malcolm looked terrible.

Unshaven.

Exhausted.

Terrified.

“I didn’t touch the girl.”

Antonio’s stare could have cracked stone.

“You spoke to her.”

“Costa ordered me to scare you.”

“By using my dead son?”

“I’m sorry.”

Antonio stepped forward.

Damen moved subtly closer.

Malcolm backed away.

“I know what happened at the hospital.”

Antonio stopped.

“Talk.”

“Costa found out Luca was sick because Brenner sold information. He planned to hit one of your warehouses while you were distracted.”

“That doesn’t explain the ICU delay.”

Malcolm swallowed.

“Brenner delayed a transport request.”

Antonio’s eyes emptied.

“On Costa’s order?”

“Yes.”

Damen cursed.

“Why?”

“Costa wanted you at the hospital longer. That’s all. He didn’t think…”

Malcolm’s voice broke.

“He didn’t think the kid would die.”

Antonio moved so fast Damen barely caught him.

Damen grabbed his arm.

“Antonio.”

Malcolm stumbled backward.

Antonio could have ordered his death.

Five years earlier he would have.

Perhaps even five days earlier.

Instead he stood trembling with rage.

Then Luca’s voice returned from memory.

A four-year-old wrapping Band-Aids around Antonio’s fingers.

Doctors help people.

Antonio released a slow breath.

“You’re going to testify.”

Malcolm stared.

“What?”

“Federal prosecutors. State prosecutors. Anyone who needs you.”

“You’ll kill me afterward.”

“No.”

“You expect me to believe that?”

Antonio looked at him.

“I’m tired of graves.”

Malcolm said nothing.

That night, Antonio returned home after midnight.

Elena was waiting.

“So?”

“We know what happened.”

He told her.

She cried.

Not because Luca’s death had been entirely caused by Costa.

It hadn’t.

But because intentional interference had stolen time from a dying child.

Daniel had discovered it years later.

And it had cost him his life.

Elena wiped her face.

“What happens now?”

Antonio looked toward the sleeping house.

“Costa expects a war.”

“And?”

“He won’t get one.”

Elena studied him.

“What will he get?”

Antonio’s expression hardened.

“Courtrooms.”

It might have been the most dangerous decision Antonio Moretti had ever made.

Not because courts frightened him.

Because choosing law meant resisting the old instincts that had ruled his life.

But for the first time in five years, Antonio was not asking what his grief wanted.

He was asking what Luca would have wanted his father to become.

---

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. No advertising trackers are enabled.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.